1"our
former alienated
condition": literally "when we were in the flesh."
Paul's perspective, of course, is from the now obtaining redeemed
state of his and his listeners' existence.
2Literally: "The passions
of sins through the Law were active in our members (body)."
I take this to mean that something beyond our control was taking
place within us and that somehow the Law was one factor in that
process.
3Literally: "to the
end of bearing fruit for death." I take this to mean that
the behavior thus described is ultimately self-destructive and/or
destructive of others, at the very least futile.
4Literally: "having
died in that where we were coerced." In other passages Paul
speaks of sinners dying with Christ and rising to new life in
a new existence that is free from sin.
5Literally: "we serve
in newness of spirit and not in oldness of letter." I take
this to mean that in the New Covenant existence one no longer
obeys God by observing precepts of the written law but through
direct discernment of and obedience to God's will as mediated
by the Holy Spirit.
6I am translating Paul's
noun ἁμαρτία,
a feminine singular abstract, as "sinfulness" rather
than as "Sin." Clearly he is not referring to an individual
sinful act but to a state or behavioral tendency in the psyche.
I am not going to comment on what Paul says about the role of
the Law and the commandment in bringing sinfulness into action
because it is not directly relevant to the parallelism with Mark
that is my chief concern here. But I will note that I have chosen
to translate the Greek form of the tenth commandment, οὐκ
ἐπιθυμήσεις,
as "You must not lust," although it is usually conveyed
by "Thou shalt not covet," or perhaps more properly,
"You must not desire what belongs to another or others."
Although I realize that I may be rendering an expansive term much
too specifically, I have chosen to convey the verb ἐπιθυμεῖν
here as "lust" because it seems to me
more meaningful in the context to understand the demonic character
of this desire and how it could trigger temptation to sin.
7Being alive" and "dying"
or "death" here are, of course, not literal in any sense
of physical life and death; they are clearly spiritual experiences
or experiences of psychic processes and states. I understand "being
alive" here to refer to integrated and efficacious selfhood
wherein the judgment and will are effectual and result in action
according with one's intentions, while "dying" is the
process of losing control over one's actions even as one may still
discern and intend what is right and good, and "death"
is the condition of impotence to effect what one discerns as right
and good and intends to do.
8Literally: "but I
am fleshly, having been sold into subjection to Sin." At
play here is the conventional language of enslavement, slave-marketing
and (ultimately) "redemption" or "buying back"
of the slave to be a free person again. Here then "a slave
sold into the power of Sinfulness" means that the speaker
is no longer free to act according to his own intentions but is
at the beck and call of a slave-master, Sinfulness, that compels
him to perform actions that are self-destructive and destructive
of others.
9This description goes the
the heart of the experience of alienation as I am using the term:
the judging and willing aspect of the psyche is split apart from
the acting aspect, so that the actions performed are not recognizable
as one's own deeds but as another's. Someone else seems to be
in control of one's body and using it quite otherwise than as
one intends.
10Here my translation is
very close to being literal. Paul uses the Greek word
οἰκεῖ, which I have translated
"has (no) dwelling" in verse 18 and "is housed"
in verse 20. This language seems very close to the image used
by Jesus in Mark 3:27 of the house of the strong man who is first
bound so that his house can be plundered. It is language consistent
with the notion of possession, where an alien force or person
seizes control of a body, as Apollo is said to seize control of
the body of his prophetess, the Sibyl, at Delphi or elsewhere.
11In the last five verses
of the chapter the Greek noun νόμος is used in several
different ways: (1) the Law (laid
down by Moses) of God; (2) "governing principle" or
"controlling factor" (a sort of automatic coercive force
clicking into operation whenever one exerts one's will; (3) "ruling
power"; this is the same as νόμος in sense (2) but now it
is represented as a personalized
force exerting a will counter to one's own will; this appears
to be the same as the next νόμος, "the ruling power of
sinfulness present within
me"-in verse 23 this is the general of an army laying siege
to one's selfhood and then taking it captive in order to make
it a slave to the general's superior, a ruler to whom one's selfhood
is now subject. Finally in verse 25 νόμος is at first "God's
(Mosaic) Law, but then must
be conveyed in English by "rule" where it is both that
automatic coercive force controlling one's behavior and at the
same time a personified master whom one is obliged to serve.
12Literally: "the body
of this death." I take this to mean "this self/body
in which the real me is trapped and powerless to act according
to my own intentions. The sense is much as that indicated earlier
in verses 9-10, "Time was when for me there was no Law and
I was alive, but when the commandment confronted me, sinfulness
sprang into life, 10 and I died, realizing, to my chagrin, that
the commandment intended to bring life actually brought about
death." The body in which one resides is not a corpse that
is can or should be buried, but it is "meat" (perhaps
the real sense of Greek σάρξ, usually translated "flesh") to be
manipulated
by another or others rather than controlled by any power resident
within it; in another sense the body or selfhood is a "corpse"
because there is no real "life"-no growth or nourishment,
no capacity to relate to other creatures, no hope whatsoever for
any meaningful existence in the future.
13In this summation Paul
gives perhaps the clearest expression in the entire passage to
the nature of alienation: the psyche is riven into two parts,
one an inner core that consents to God's will and that intends
to perform it, the other a body or acting self that carries out
acts that are evil, devastating to one's self and to others.